Will Uncharted 4 Beat Bloodborne’s Record For Highest Rated Exclusive?

Both the PlayStation 4 and the Xbox One have had some pretty good exclusive games this generation. Games like Sunset Overdrive, Infamous Second Son, Forza Motorsport 6 and more. All of those have received some great reviews but the one that stands above the rest is the PS4 exclusive Bloodborne. To date it is the highest rated exclusive between the two platforms not counting remasters. Bloodborne has an average review score of 92 according to Metacritic making it not only the highest rated exclusive of this gen but one of the highest rated games of this gen period. However, could Bloodborne be about to hand that crown off to another game?

That game I’m referring to is none other than Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End of course which is only a month away from launch now on the PlayStation 4. The question is: Will Uncharted 4 beat out Bloodborne and become the highest rated exclusive of this generation? In my personal opinion I think it will and here is why I believe that. The main reason is because it’s being made by Naughty Dog who has been on a incredible roll with putting out not only highly rated games but also games that have gone on to become huge Game of the Year winners. Going back to the original Uncharted on the PS3 the Metacritic scores for their games are: Uncharted 1 – 88, Uncharted 2 – 96, Uncharted 3 – 92, The Last of Us – 95. Those are some pretty incredible scores and not many other studios have had that impressive of a streak.


Of those four games Uncharted 2 and The Last of Us went on to win the most Game of the Year awards of any other game released in both 2009 and 2013. Uncharted 3 also won some Game of the Year awards in 2011 but it wasn’t the big winner that year. Now the thing that both Uncharted 2 and The Last of Us have in common is that both Neil Druckmann and Bruce Straley played a big part in creating both of them. They both worked on Uncharted 2 and then moved on to creating The Last of Us and didn’t play a part in making Uncharted 3. Some people think that is why Uncharted 3 was viewed widely as not being as good as Uncharted 2. With both of them in charge of The Last of Us they produced another impressively reviewed game and it went on to win over 200 GOTY awards. Both Druckmann and Straley are once again in charge of Uncharted 4 so if you go by their past work I’d say Uncharted 4 could certainly become the highest rated exclusive this generation.

uncharted 4

I also believe Uncharted 4 will claim that title as all the impressions from the press who have gotten to play it have been nothing but positive. Naughty Dog isn’t just using the same formula again and instead of opted to change a lot of things about the game. The environments are a lot bigger than they have ever been encouraging players to explore more rather than just go from point A to point B like past Uncharted games did. The gameplay also allows you to go in guns blazing or be more stealthy if you choose. You can tell Naughty Dog learned a lot from working on The Last of Us and is now bringing many of those things to Uncharted 4. Hey if they worked so well in the past why not bring them to Uncharted 4 right? The graphics in the game are just mind blowing as well. I don’t think any other console game looks anywhere close to as impressive as what we’ve seen from Uncharted 4. Naughty Dog has always gotten the most out of the PlayStation in the past and It’s looking like their going to do it again.

So those are just a few reasons why I think Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End will beat out Bloodborne and become the highest rated exclusive this generation. If I had to make a prediction I’d say Uncharted 4 ends up with at least a 94 Metacritic score which would be very impressive. We are only a month away from finding out. What do you think? Do you think Uncharted 4 will claim that title? Why or why not? Tell us in the comments below.

Have your say!

0 0


  1. I think you better check your fact because TLOU Remastered has the highest PS4 Exclusive score at 95 !

    • Hi if you read my article you would have read that I was not counting remasters. It says that write in the article. I was talking about new games only between the PS4 and Xbox One.
      “To date it is the highest rated exclusive between the two platforms not counting remasters.”

      • Even so Super Mario 3D World (WiiU) with 93, Followed by Bloodborne (PS4) and Journey (PS4) tied at 92. So that still means Bloodborne isn’t the highest scoring game.

        • Again this article was comparing the PS4 and the Xbox One. Not the Wii U. Also Journey counts as a remaster as it was originally on PS3 and therefore didn’t count just like The Last of Us. Bloodborne is the highest rated PS4 exclusive and that is what the article was comparing Uncharted 4 to.

          • LOL Well I guess when you eliminate every game with a higher score then yes but then theres no point to the article. Unless you just have a real hard on for Bloodborne. Even So Bloodborne wasn’ near as good a game as TLOU. NO game in gaming history has ever hit the heights TLOU has it was a perfect masterpiece and 232 GOTY awards confirm it.

          • Many sites eliminate remasters from discussions. Why should they count when they are just ports of older games. We are talking about exclusives that are EXCLUSIVE to the new gen consoles. Journey and TLOU are exactly the same as they were on PS3 just with some graphical enhancements. Btw The Witcher 3 won more GOTY awards than TLOU did. 253 to be exact. Sorry you disagree with the article but that doesn’t mean the article is wrong. You just didn’t read it as it was intended to be read.

          • Sorry to disagree with you but NO Game has won more GOTY awards then the TLOU. I can’t beleive you expect me to acept that the wichter 3 won more awrds and I never heard or read anything about it. If you think The Witcher 3 won more then please site your source.

          • This site lists every award a game has won every year. TLOU won 249 and The Witcher 3 currently sitting at 253. It’s been said several different places that Witcher 3 has won more than 250+ GOTY awards as well. Do some research next time. http://gotypicks.blogspot.com/?m=1

  2. Probably there will be a lot of hate towards u4 and crazy nick-picking which might reduce the overall score. Having playing all previous parts I don’t care about score, I will play it day one.

  3. No it will probably be the highest rated game of the genreation so far to be beaten by The Last of Us 2 then, then to be beaten by Jak 4 🙂

Comments are now closed for this post.

Lost Password

Please enter your username or email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.